COLUMN: Beware the middle class bunnies

Freedom to Read Week at the Library

Some years ago the London County Council in England banned Beatrix Potter’s children’s classics The Tale of Peter Rabbit and Benjamin Bunny from London schools. Why? Because the stories portrayed only “middle-class rabbits.”

I love this little tale, pulled from Freedom to Read Canada’s website under “Bannings and Burnings in History”, for its sheer ridiculousness. Freedom to Read aims to be an antidote to a history intellectual prohibition.

There will be plenty of food for unfettered thought at this year’s Freedom to Read event at the Library on Thursday, March 1 at 7pm. Police Chief Paul Burkhart, children’s author Cyndi Sand-Eveland, father-son reading duo Greg and Jake Maslak, filmmaker Amy Bohigian, poet Jane Byers, educator and actor Geoff Burns, and Chief Librarian Tracey Therrien take the stage to read from books that have been challenged for the right to be in schools and libraries.

It’s not all about bourgeois bunnies; book banning goes way back. Roman emperor Caligula found The Odyssey by Homer much too dangerous for his people to read, expressing, as it does, Greek ideas of freedom. History proves that those in power tend to wield a heavy hand against literature they don’t like: Queen Elizabeth I took exception to Shakespeare’s Richard II in 1597; later, King Lear was banned for 40 years. The Nazis under Adolf Hitler burned books by Jack London and Ernest Hemingway. Recently, U.S. president Donald Trump did his level best to stop the publication of Michael Wolfe’s exposé Fire and Fury.

In Canada, most challenges come from parents and parent groups targeting books for kids and teens. It’s not always as ridiculous as the societal leanings of a few carrot-stealing lagomorphs; some subjects can make a sensitive child—or parent—squirm. But challenge can also be opportunity.

Author Dav Pilkey, whose Captain Underpants series for kids is among the most challenged in America, suggests a tweak to the narrative. In a delightful YouTube video about freedom to read, he advocates for parental involvement in their kids’ reading. Instead of “I don’t want children to read this book” he suggests using “my children”. The same goes for “That book does not belong in a library”; the insertion of “my” in place of “a” acknowledges everyone’s right to choose freely. We don’t all alike the same things, nor should we, he says. But we should all get to choose.

Margaret Atwood’s often-challenged book The Handmaid’s Tale is a great point of departure for classroom discussion at the high school level about sexual degradation and other themes—the very thing a recent objection was about. Annie Proulx’s Wyoming Stories, which includes the short story—later a movie—“Brokeback Mountain”, was challenged scenes of homosexuality (the library retained the book) and Timothy Finley’s modern classic The Wars is likewise challenged (also kept in the high school curriculum). If we don’t discuss these things, how will we understand them?

It’s true that some books don’t hold up to today’s societal attitudes. The 1932 graphic novel Tintin in America is certainly guilty of racial stereotyping of First Nations people. Older works by Dr. Seuss fall into that category, as does the picture book Little Black Sambo, later reworked into a new iteration called Little Babaji. These sorts of books will quietly go out of print as we embrace more inclusive attitudes. So what do you do if you find one of these on the Library shelves?

Pilkey suggests that instead of “I should complain about that book,” try: “I should discuss that book with my family,” reminding us—as Freedom to Read Week in Canada champions— that the freedom to choose what we read or think about is a hard-won right, and that anything else is a slippery slope indeed.

Anne DeGrace is the Adult Services Coordinator at the Nelson Public Library. Check This Out runs every other week.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Comments are closed

Just Posted

Four members of Nelson and District Women’s Centre board resign

Centre is closed during COVID-19 and is currently hiring an executive director

Reflecting on former Kootenay MLA Ed Conroy’s legacy

Former BC cabinet minister and Kootenay MLA Ed Conroy passed away June 26

Civic Theatre gets $2.7 million to add two more screens

The grant will allow two small theatres to be built in the back of the current auditorium

Salmo RCMP arrest three, seize $15,000

The three adult men have been charged with “Conspiracy to Commit an Offence.”

Nelson graduate student wins prestigious Vanier Scholarship

Sienna Drake, studying at McGill University, will receive $50,000 per year for the next three years

Police issue warning after baby comes across suspected drugs in Kamloops park

The 11-month-old girl’s mother posted photos on social media showing a small plastic bag containing a purple substance

Collision results in train derailment just east of Golden

The derailment occurred Sunday night, according to a statement from CP

Lower Mainland woman says llama farming neighbour shot her 11-month-old pup

Young dog was on owner’s Maple Ridge property when it was killed on June 21

B.C. records 31 new cases, six deaths over three days due to COVID-19

There are 166 active cases in B.C., 16 people in hospital

B.C. highway widening job reduced, costs still up $61 million

Union-only project scales back work to widen Trans-Canada

Greater Victoria nanny pleads guilty to child porn, sexual interference charges

Johnathon Lee Robichaud pleaded guilty to slew of sex crimes

Most Read