Atamanenko gets it right

I read your recent editorial (“Why pay for the military,” December 2) when it was reprinted in part in the Globe and Mail.

  • Dec. 15, 2011 5:00 p.m.

I read your recent editorial (“Why pay for the military,” December 2) when it was reprinted in part in the Globe and Mail.

Alex Atamanenko’s private member’s bill proposes that a citizen who is a conscientious objector, and is willing to register as such, will be able to have a portion of her/his taxes placed in a special conscientious objectors’ account. The funds from that account would then be used for any non-military peace building purposes.

First, what is wrong with this idea? Our society (and many others) allows persons who are conscientious objectors to refuse to perform military service. As defined by Wikipedia, a conscientious objector is an “individual who has claimed the right to refuse to perform military service” on the grounds of freedom of thought, conscience, and/or religion. Are you against this right? If Canadians have a right to refuse to work for war, why not allow Canadians to not pay for war?

Second, you warn of a “slippery slope” that this proposed option might open. It is very hard for me to imagine how a conscientious objection to tax allocations for support of the elderly, child care, the CBC or health care could be made. Of course it is possible, in a democratic, pluralistic and multicultural society, that there are other tax expenditures against which objections on moral basis can be made, and it would be consistent for Parliament to weigh each on it merits.

Third, I find it hard to understand how turning over prisoners to torture, hiring mercenary corporations, or buying billions of dollars worth of jet fighters is safeguarding my freedom.

Fourth, your jingoistic call to support the government, whatever it does, sounds like the mentality that breeds fascism, totalitarianism and got the world in trouble before. I agree that “…we are in this together.” I also believe that in a democratic society, the rights we enjoy come with a shared responsibility for the actions and programs of our government. I believe, therefore, that my right to dissent from paying for the Afghanistan War, the Libyan War, or any war is also my duty and responsibility as a citizen.

Fifth, your closing cheap shot that Alex should spend his time more productively: I happen to think that proposing a peace tax is a productive use of his time. You don’t. If you had read Hansard, you would learn that on the same day, Alex called for a strengthening of the Criminal Code to increase the penalty for making child pornography from the current 90 day sentence by recognizing it as a form of child abuse. And you would also have learned that even later that same day, Alex spoke very strongly and eloquently against the dismantling of the Wheat Board.

You may not agree with the position he takes, but the reality is that Alex is one of the Canada’s hardest working MPs and we are fortunate to have him working for us.

Vincent Salvo



Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Trial date set in Castlegar RCMP shooting death

Constable Jason Tait has elected a jury trial.

RDCK recycling depots to join RecycleBC program

Some depots open, others close, and different materials will be accepted

Morning start: This famous singer is from the West Kootenays

Here is your Kootenays’ morning start for Tuesday, May 26

Help the Nelson Star continue its mission to provide trusted local news

Black Press is now accepting donations to keep its papers operating

B.C. mom’s drug-pricing petition on behalf of son garners thousands of signatures

Petition geared to gaining access to new medicines drew support of Chilliwack-Hope MP Mark Strahl

‘Paralyzed by fear’: B.C. woman details anxiety, grief at Italian relief hospital

Sheila Vicic spent two months in Italy as the country grappled with COVID-19

Dr. Bonnie Henry given new name in B.C. First Nation ceremony: ‘one who is calm among us’

The provincial health officer was honoured in a May 22 ceremony at elementary school in Hazelton

CAMH survey looks at binge-drinking, financial anxiety during COVID

Alcohol may be used as a coping mechanism for those whose careers may have been sidelined due to the pandemic

Half of Canadians say governments are hiding something about COVID-19: poll

More than a third of people believe the virus was created in a lab

Kelowna man charged with harming a hamster

The 20-year-old Kelowna man faces several animal cruelty charges

High tech fish transport system set up to ‘whoosh’ salmon past Big Bar landslide

Fish will spend roughly 20 seconds inside the system, moving at roughly 20 metres per second

Most Read