Biomass identified as best option for Nelson energy system

A new energy system for a block of city-owned buildings in downtown Nelson is now expected to use biomass rather than geothermal heating.

Corporate energy coordinator Fiona Galbraith addresses Nelson city council Monday about plans for a district energy system.

Work on a new energy system for a block of city-owned buildings in downtown Nelson is moving ahead, but is now expected to use biomass rather than geothermal heating.

A feasibility study completed in August found biomass would make the most economic sense. It would use wood waste from local mills and reduce greenhouse gas emissions by about 1,200 tonnes per year.

The buildings expected to be included in the project’s first phase are the Civic Centre, community complex, curling club, and indoor soccer facility, which are all adjacent.

The project would cost anywhere from $2.3 million to $6.3 million and take 16 to 30 years to pay for itself.

Nelson Hydro says it is further researching capital costs, but has already found the greatest cost differences are in civil works and energy transfer stations required to move heat from the system to each customer. The lower-end estimate doesn’t include costs such as acquiring land or retrofits to tie buildings into the system.

“The expenses included in the estimates will be confirmed and merged into a final cost estimate,” a memo to city council from Nelson Hydro general manager Alex Love and corporate energy coordinator Fiona Galbraith reads. “This refined cost estimate will have a high enough degree of accuracy to assess the business case for a district energy system.”

The refined estimate is expected in early 2015. Nelson Hydro also wants to look for potential sites for a central plant, seek grants to speed up the payback time, and do an engineering analysis.

Originally the city was thinking about an energy system that would use Kootenay Lake for heating and cooling, but Galbraith and Love told city council Monday that while it is technically feasible, the cost recovery would not be as swift as with biomass.

“In an apples-to-apples comparison, [the consultant] said biomass is the best,” Love said. “The challenge now is to reign the variety of options down to a manageable few. We look forward to bringing forward for council’s consideration a business case in the fairly near future.”

Love said the plant needs to be centrally located, no more than one kilometer from the buildings it serves, and could fit on a space the size of the community complex’s lower parking lot. Depending on the amount spent, Love said it could look like anything, from a “steel-clad industrial building” to a timber-framed building with windows “that looks fairly attractive.”

Depending on the option chosen, there would be very little particulate emissions, he said. At one plant they toured, “you were hard pressed to see something coming out of the stack.”

Galbraith said despite the wide spread in cost estimates, she expected the final price tag to fall between $3 million and $4 million.

A 2012 fibre supply study found no shortage of waste wood within a 120 km radius of Nelson. “It’s now stockpiled,” Galbraith said. “They don’t know what to do with it. They said ‘We’d be happy if you would take it off our hands.’”

(CORRECTION: An earlier version of this story said a biomass system would generate carbon emissions roughly equivalent to natural gas. However, although biomass has carbon content, it does not contribute to greenhouse gas emissions in the same way as natural gas.)

Just Posted

Finding support at Community Connect

The 10th annual event offered free services, clothing and food on Saturday

RDCK calls for reversal of Sinixt extinction

The board opposed a land transfer to the Westbank First Nation this week

Nelson city council to update banner policy

Council will revisit the wording of the policy at its December meeting

Forecasters promote avalanche safety awareness

Avalanche Canada advising backcountry enthusiasts to get proper training and equipment.

Meteorite fragments found near Crawford Bay

The pieces came from the fireball that exploded over Kootenay Lake in September

VIDEO: Rare comic showing Superman’s 1st appearance to be auctioned

The 1938 comic features Superman hoisting a car over his head

Man pleads guilty to Leafs recycling depot theft

Dezmond Waggoner had been charged with theft over $5,000

Nelson Leafs stretch winning streak to six

Jack Karran scored twice in the Leafs 6-3 win over Fernie

Nelson city hall selling bear-proof garbage bins

The city has purchased 100 bins and is charging residents $205

COLUMN: Will West Kootenay forests survive?

As with most things around ecology, the answer is not simple, says columnist Greg Utzig

Julien Locke races to NST World Cup berth

Black Jack cross-country skier Julien Locke races to first place at World Cup qualifier

B.C. reporter reflects on covering Charles Manson

Charles Manson, leader of a murderous cult, died on Sunday at 83

Most Read