UPDATED: Driver found guilty in Lemon Creek case, government acquitted

More detail following our brief story on Thursday

Danny Lasante has been found guilty of polluting a stream when the fuel truck he was driving went off a forest road and landed in Lemon Creek in 2013.

The provincial government, also charged, was acquitted Thursday in Nelson court.

Lasante was convicted of one count under the Environmental Management Act for causing the spill of about 35,000 litres of jet fuel into the creek. Lasante’s employer, Executive Flight Centre, was supplying fuel to the provincial government to fight a forest fire at the time.

The spill polluted the Slocan river, resulting in an evacuation and orders not to drink the water.

Judge Lisa Mrozinski found that even though Lasante was not given precise directions by his employer, Executive Flight Centre, regarding which road to take when leaving Highway 6, it was his actions once he had left the highway that caused the spill.

According to Mrozinski’s written reasons for judgement, shortly after Lasante had turned onto Lemon Creek Road he encountered several signs stating that the road was closed and was unmaintained.

He continued on, already realizing he was on the wrong road, then drove over a particularly narrow curved portion of road that required him to run his wheels off the travelled part of the road on the creek side. Shortly thereafter he turned around, again travelling the narrow curve, on which the road shoulder gave way and his truck slid into the creek.

Mrozinski ruled that Lasante did not take proper precautions when faced with an unmaintained road and signage to indicate that it was closed.

“Mr. Lasante did nothing to assure himself he was on a safe road. He made no inquiries; he made no effort to get his bearings; he did not step out of his vehicle to examine the road. In these circumstances, I find that Mr. Lasante has not met his onus to establish on balance that he had a reasonably held belief the road was safe at the point where the spill occurred.”

Related:

Lemon Creek charges stayed against fuel company (Oct. 2017)

Crown appeals stay of charges in Lemon Creek case (Dec. 2017)

There was much discussion in the trial and in Mrozinski’s reasons about the instructions Lasante did or did not receive from Executive Flight Centre and from the Ministry of Forests about which road to take from Highway 6. She found that even though those directions could have been better, they did not cause the accident.

She also found the provincial government not guilty.

“I have found the spill occurred because Mr. Lasante failed to exercise the degree of care a reasonable person would have exercised in the circumstances. Part of that finding is based on my finding that the signs posted by the Ministry of Transportation and Infrastructure (MOTI) on Lemon Creek Road should have been sufficient to warn any reasonable driver, let alone a driver holding a class 1 license hauling a dangerous substance, that danger lay ahead. To the extent MOTI was obliged to take all reasonable steps to avoid this spill, I find it did so by the signage it posted along Lemon Creek road: signage which indicated the road was not only unmaintained but that it was closed.”

Executive Flight Centre was originally a defendant in the case but charges were dropped in October because delays between the initial charges and the trial prejudiced a fair hearing. That decision is currently under appeal. Lasante also attempted to have Mrozinski stay the changes against him for reasons of delay, but Mrozinski rejected this, saying the delay in Lasante’s case was not as long.

The Lemon Creek pollution case began as a private prosecution by Slocan Valley resident Marilyn Burgoon before it was taken over by the federal Crown.

“I am disappointed,” Burgoon said after Thursday’s court decision. “I thought it should have been a shared responsibility. I think what is most disappointing is that Executive Flight Centre has not been held accountable at all, and that is why there is an appeal.”

“It does not give me much confidence in the government to be in control of anything they do,” she added. “To me the most responsible should be the government who is the overseer of all of this.”

Lasante will be sentenced on April 3.

Related:

Related: Private prosecution launched over Lemon Creek spill

Feds take over Lemon Creek Case

Feds lay charges in Lemon Creek case



bill.metcalfe@nelsonstar.com

Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter

Just Posted

Here we go again: Mamma Mia! set to open at the Capitol Theatre

The ABBA-inspired musical runs Thursday to Sunday

Nelson holds the line on property taxes

No increase this year thanks to deal with RDCK on park funding

25 years of Nite Trek for West Kootenay Scouts, Guides

Annual adventure hike is hosted by the 107th Baden Powell Guild

Company granted leave to appeal Lemon Creek charges

Executive Flight Centre won a decision in the BC Court of Appeal

Police: cougar still wandering Nelson

The cougar was seen in Lakeside Park

Killer of Calgary mother, daughter gets no parole for 50 years

A jury found Edward Downey guilty last year in the deaths of Sara Baillie, 34, and five-year-old Taliyah Marsman

Most British Columbians agree the ‘big one’ is coming, but only 50% are prepared

Only 46 per cent of British Columbians have prepared an emergency kit with supplies they might need

B.C. man to pay Maxime Bernier’s People’s Party $20k over lawsuit

Federal judge shut down Satinder Dhillon’s ‘nonsensical’ motion to bar use of PPC name in byelection

Sitting and sleeping on downtown sidewalks could net $100 fine in Penticton

The measure, which still requires final approval, would be enforced between May and Sept. 30

Survey finds 15% of Canadian cannabis users with a valid licence drive within two hours of using

Survey also finds middle-aged men are upping their usage following legalization

B.C. man killed in logging accident ‘would have done anything for anyone’

Wife remembers 43-year old Petr Koncek, father of two children

Ottawa spending $24.5M to research on health benefits, risks of pot use

$390,000 will fund two cannabis public awareness

Most Read