One of the maps included with a report last May showing the risk level Johnsons Landing residents face.

Johnsons Landing residents ponder property values

Although her Johnsons Landing home wasn’t directly affected by the landslide, it changed Gail Spitler’s future.

Second of three parts

Although her Johnsons Landing home wasn’t directly affected by the landslide that cut through the community in 2012, it changed Gail Spitler’s future.

Spitler, 73, owns ten acres with a house and outbuildings. Before the slide, she didn’t see herself staying in the community much longer.

“The plan was of course to sell this place and move into something more urban and smaller,” she says. “Those plans are definitely on hold.”

Spitler’s property assessment fell 15 per cent a year ago and she was surprised when it was reduced a further 17 per cent on her most recent notice, bringing it close to the original price she paid in 1991.

“You would think if we’re going to get stigmatized, it’s going to happen once and that would be enough,” she says. “The kicker is that nobody knows what the selling price would be.”

Johnsons Landing is made up of two benches, only one of which was affected by the slide, although that distinction isn’t always clear to those not from the area — hence the stigma the BC Assessment Authority recognized when it reduced values outside the evacuation zone by up to 50 per cent.

Whether the decrease is good, bad, or indifferent, Spitler isn’t sure. She has heard of a young couple privately trying to sell a small piece of land, but there haven’t been any takers. “Properties move very slowly here. It’s a matter of finding the exact person who wants to live here.”

‘Tarred and feathered’

Clint Carlson has six acres of waterfront with a house, close to but outside the evacuation zone, which he bought six weeks before the slide. He has since watched his assessment drop by about half, which he considers fair, though he’s troubled by the stigma which he blames on the regional district and media.

“To pay half the taxes while the area recovers I think is sensible. My feeling is that the whole community has been tarred and feathered badly with the evacuation order,” he says. “They haven’t come out and said ‘A good portion of Johnsons Landing is as it was.‘ Everybody’s wearing the same brush.”

Carlson’s family has long roots in the community: his father was a relative of its namesake, Algot Johnson, and inherited his farm in the 1960s. Carlson grew up there and his family has owned different portions over the years.

He doesn’t feel at risk. “I wouldn’t suggest plunking a house in the middle of the slide zone, but they’ve modelled [the slide] with volumes significantly higher than what came down, and it doesn’t change anything as far as my house,” he says. “It’s as good a place as it ever was, except visual aesthetics, which are already improving like crazy.”

Carlson noted the downside to reduced assessments is for those borrowing money.

‘Value is zip’

Greg Utzig has a cabin on 7½ acres adjacent to the slide, the lower corner of which falls in the evacuation zone. His assessment initially dropped about 15 per cent last year and a bit further on appeal.

This year it fell another 40 per cent, and he’s hoping to have it reduced even more, based on the fact the regional district recently extended its evacuation order.

“In my view it means nothing’s worth anything because who’s going to buy a property with that kind of uncertainty?” he asks. “I’ve talked with various appraisers. They said it’s basically zero. Assessed value is supposed to reflect market value, but if there are no purchasers, the value is zip.”

Utzig and partner Donna Macdonald, a Nelson city councillor, still use the cabin, although they park in and walk through the evacuation zone to access it.

As a soil scientist, Utzig acknowledges the risk, which may range from negligible to substantial depending on the time of year, but he isn’t worried.

“The risk driving to Johnsons Landing is probably higher than being in Johnsons Landing,” he says. “There’s either a slide or avalanche north of Lardeau twice a year. You have to put these risks in perspective.”

Utzig called the slide a climate-change related event, one of many that will likely occur over the coming decades, and hoped it would serve as a “learning opportunity.”

However, he doesn’t feel government is approaching it that way, pointing to the lack of formal monitoring to collect additional data (an informal program exists, spearheaded by the Ministry of Forests with help from volunteers).

While the province provided financial compensation to residents whose primary homes were lost, it has stated there is no mechanism to buy out entire neighborhoods affected by disaster. The government maintains the slide was an act of god for which it bears no liability.

Utzig said he and others with second residences aren’t in as dire straights as those whose assets were tied up in now-worthless properties where they can’t rebuild.

He’s optimistic the assessment authority may drop his assessment further. “I think they‘re operating in good faith and trying to take a good approach,” he said. “It’s an unprecedented situation.”

Next: A realtor’s view

Previous: Stigma sees Johnsons Landing assessments drop

Just Posted

Grease comes to the Capitol Theatre

The production runs Thursday to Sunday

COLUMN: Watching water, thinking about elections

Columnist Donna Macdonald spoke to Prince George councillor Jillian Merrick about inclusiveness

UPDATE: City opens emergency operations centre

Lakeside Park, its sports fields, and parts of the waterfront could soon be underwater

Canada, U.S. to begin Columbia River Treaty negotiations on May 29

B.C. MLA Katrine Conroy will represent the province in the talks

VIDEO: How to use naloxone to stop a fentanyl overdose

ANKORS’ Chloe Sage shows what to do when someone is overdosing

Police release video on how to ‘run, hide, fight’ if there’s an active shooter

Vancouver police offer video with input from E-Comm, BC EHS, Vancouver Fire and Rescue

Horgan defends fight to both retain and restrict Alberta oil imports

Alberta says pipeline bottlenecks are kneecapping the industry, costing millions of dollars a day

RCMP caution boaters after two kids pass out from carbon monoxide poisoning

Both children were given oxygen and taken to hospital

B.C. invests $115M to create 200 new nurse practitioner jobs

Health Minister says 780,000 B.C. residents don’t have a family doctor

Supreme Court rules social housing residents in B.C. deserve rights too

Tenants trying to stabilize their living situations should not face less legal rights than those paying market rates: Judge

Union calls on prime minister to step into ‘stalled’ Phoenix compensation talks

For more than two years, thousands of federal workers have been affected by Phoenix system

Judge: President Trump can’t block critics on Twitter

The judge had suggested that Trump mute rather than block some of his critics

NFL owners adopt new policy to address anthem protests

Commissioner Roger Goodell said the change was approved unanimously by owners

Unicyclist starts his cross-Canada trip in Vancouver

Taylor Stark started his journey May 7

Most Read