A judge has awarded Charity Mason damages stemming from a police search in Nelson almost five years ago.

Judge awards woman $500 over Nelson police search

Although he rejected most of her arguments, a judge has ordered the City of Nelson to pay a woman $500 in damages over a police search.

Although he rejected most of her arguments, a judge has ordered the City of Nelson to pay a woman $500 in damages over a police search conducted almost five years ago.

Charity Mason sued the city, Cst. Drew Turner, and then-chief Dan Maluta after the pick-up truck she and partner Vaughn Blais were in was pulled over on the south end of the orange bridge on the morning of June 26, 2009 for a possible traffic violation.

Blais initially got out of the truck and began yelling at Turner, who ordered him to get back in. When he approached the vehicle, Turner said he smelled the “very strong odour” of vegetative marijuana. He  searched the vehicle along with Mason, Blais, and a hitchhiker who was with them, but found no drugs.

He did, however, seize $7,420 in cash found in a ziplock bag in Mason’s purse as potential proceeds of crime. Blais gave her the money that morning and told police it was from the sale of a boat, but was unable to provide specifics.

The trio was detained for about 45 minutes and then released without formal arrest or charge. Because Blais had a criminal record for violent and drug offences, Maluta and RCMP Cst. Tony Holland both responded to provide Turner with back-up.

Mason, who said she suffered humiliation and ongoing emotional distress, sued over the search, claiming it was “without warrant or reasonable cause” and breached her privacy and Charter rights. However, Turner denied the allegations and said he used reasonable care, skill, and diligence at all times.

Mason, now 30, represented herself in a 3½ day trial last fall before BC Supreme Court Justice Peter Voith, who in his ruling called her “bright and articulate” and said she “worked very diligently to organize and advance her case.”

However, at the end of the second day of testimony, he granted a motion to dismiss the case against Maluta, agreeing Mason had not introduced any evidence against him.

Voith said he accepted the testimony of each witness “in the main,” although he was troubled by Mason’s assertion that she didn’t know what Blais did for a living. When asked if he was a drug dealer, she replied “not to my knowledge.” Although he played a central role in the case, Blais did not testify at the trial.

Voith found that while police witnesses gave sometimes inaccurate evidence, it was due to memory lapses.

He concluded Turner was justified in stopping the truck and had reason to be concerned about his safety. He also accepted that Turner smelled marijuana and had reasonable grounds to arrest and search the vehicle’s occupants.

He further held that the pat-down Mason received during the search was conducted reasonably and disagreed with her claim that it constituted a sexual assault.

While Mason argued the roadside search, visible to the public, “heightened her embarrassment,” Voith accepted police testimony that a search in private would increase the risk of “assertions of impropriety.”

Voith ruled, however, that Turner didn’t inform any of the three of their Charter rights, although Maluta and Holland assumed it had been provided when they arrived.

Turner indicated he would have provided a Charter warning had he found drugs on anyone. His lawyer admitted Turner failed to advise Mason of her right to counsel “without delay” but suggested the error was merely “technical.”

The judge disagreed. Voith said the violation, “though not malicious or high-handed” was serious enough to require an award “that satisfies the object of deterring future similar breaches.”

He awarded damages of $500, to be paid by the City of Nelson, and dismissed all other claims.

The full judgement can be found here.

Just Posted

Selkirk College nursing students visit Honduran migrants

Students were overwhelmed by migrants’ hope in the face of poverty and displacement

Feds, B.C. to expand Darkwoods Conservation area

New funding allows the national land trust to add some 7,900 hectares to the Darkwoods Conservation Area

Good fencing makes good neighbours— especially when your neighbours are bears

Workshop in Pass Creek this weekend to promote benefits of proper protection for livestock

Laird Creek residents still hoping for independent report on logging road

Logging company wants to reopen road that residents believe caused slide in 2011

Kootenay region posts 10-per-cent return rate on electoral reform ballots

As of Nov. 13, only 5.3 per cent of ballots had been returned province-wide

Older B.C. drivers subsidizing younger ones, study finds

ICBC protects higher-risk drivers, pays for testing costs

EU divorce deal in peril after two UK Cabinet ministers quit

Negotiators from Britain and the European Union have struck a proposed divorce deal that will be presented to politicians on both sides for approval, officials in London and Brussels said Tuesday.

Feds respond to sexual assault investigation at B.C. naval base

Report of Oct. 5 sexual assault on Vancouver Island base taken over by Canadian Forces National Investigation Service

Northern California fire death toll at 56; 130 missing

Many of the missing are elderly and from Magalia, a forested town of about 11,000 to the north of Paradise.

Canfor to buy 70 per cent stake in Swedish Vida Group for $580 million

The privately held company has nine sawmills in southern Sweden with an annual production capacity of 1.1 billion board feet.

Saudi prosecutor seeks death penalty in Khashoggi’s killing

Saudi Arabia’s top prosecutor is recommending the death penalty for five suspects charged with ordering and carrying out the killing of Saudi writer Jamal Khashoggi.

Mixing business and family: Trudeau turns to Singapore ancestors to widen trade

Trudeau’s ancestor, Esther Bernard, born Farquhar (1796-1838) was the daughter of Major-General William Farquhar (1774-1839), the first British Resident and Commandant of Singapore.

Baloney Meter: Will tougher penalties for gang members make Canada safer?

Since 2013, gang-related homicides in Canada’s largest cities have almost doubled

Most Read