Marilyn James is seen at a rally near the courthouse in March. She is defending herself against allegations of criminal contempt of court.

Judgement reserved in Perry Ridge contempt case

A BC Supreme Court judge will announce June 24 whether he thinks a Sinixt woman should be found in criminal contempt.

A BC Supreme Court judge will rule June 24 whether he thinks a Sinixt woman violated a court injunction and should be found in criminal contempt.

Marilyn James was arrested March 4 on the Perry Ridge forest service road in the Slocan Valley for allegedly breaching an injunction granted the previous day to Galena Contracting which prevented anyone from blocking the road.

A co-accused, Dennis Zarelli, pled guilty and received a 14-day conditional sentence. James, however, denies obstructing the company, which had a contract to extend the road for BC Timber Sales.

She argues crews were already at work when she arrived that morning and she did not have a key to the locked gate where she stood, whereas Galena owner Ray Hascarl did. She also claimed police didn’t verify whether she was impeding his access before arresting her.

Local Sinixt and their supporters maintained a camp just past the gate to protect what they say are their cultural sites. However, the provincial government does not officially recognize them as a First Nation.

On the final day of her trial last week, James testified she believed Galena “colluded” with the RCMP and Attorney-General to “entrap” her.

Under cross-examination, Crown counsel Iain Currie asked James repeatedly if she was there to prevent Hascarl from reaching the work site.

“I went up to stake my claim and tell Mr. Hascarl that he is a colonial thug,” she replied. She ultimately agreed she was prepared to block Hascarl, but added that she didn’t need to do so that day.

“You knew he was testing whether you would comply with the injunction?” Currie asked. “We knew the injunction existed and he was trying to entrap us,” James answered.

In his closing submission, Currie said the evidence showed James defied the injunction and by inviting others to join her on Perry Ridge, “indicated a knowledge and intention that the court’s authority would be depreciated.”

He argued that while James didn’t specifically state she wouldn’t let Hascarl pass, neither did she step aside when asked. Currie said under the circumstances, it constituted physically impeding Hascarl, contrary to the injunction.

“She went to Perry Ridge to assert her obviously deeply held and sincere position, determined to safeguard her people’s rights. In doing so, however, she defied this court’s injunction.”

James, who is representing herself, said in her closing statement that it was “premature to grant injunctions” when the Sinixt’s title claim hasn’t been resolved, which “makes lower courts susceptible to squashing the rights of aboriginal people.”

Justice Mark McEwan told James he was “prepared to accept you have a sincere belief there is a higher law than the law of BC and that before the laws are reconciled the government shouldn’t allow logging when there’s a question who’s entitled to the property.”

However, James said: “You’re going to do the same thing that all the other courts have done. Not look at once sentence … Not test the responsibilities of the court in any way or weigh or measure the evidence before you. That’s the treatment we’ve got from the courts for the last 25 years. I don’t expect anything else from you.”

James shouted at McEwan through most of the proceedings but also thanked him “for being very reasonable with me and explaining procedures.”

Just Posted

Cardiac arrest survivor saved by passerby

People who know CPR can now register with a new phone app to notify them of nearby emergencies

Pedestrian killed on Highway 22 Saturday evening

Police say 51-year-old man died after being hit by car

LETTER: Concern for fossil fuel subsidies

From reader Marylee Banyard

Nelson Leafs overcome injuries to beat Fernie 3-1

Hunter Young made 26 saves in net for the Leafs

1st Indigenous woman to start Canadian airline looks to B.C.’s remote regions

Teara Fraser is the first Indigenous woman in Canada to start her own airline, called Iskwew Air

Canadian Armed Forces to change approach to sexual assault investigations

New program aimed at a more open and transparent process, will consult with civilians, health and law professionals

UPDATE: Death of 38-year-old Fernie man at B.C. coal mine under investigation

Vehicle collision occurred at approximately 10:45 a.m. Sunday morning

Breathing polluted air during pregnancy may increase odds of baby having autism: SFU study

Study looked at nearly all births in Metro Vancouver between 2004 and 2009

Six students arrested, charged in sex assault probe at Toronto all-boys school

The school’s principal, Greg Reeves, described the video of the alleged sexual assault as ‘horrific’

Bankruptcies in British Columbia on the rise

Consumer bankruptcies climbed by 6. 1 per cent in August 2018 from the same month last year.

22 public toilets in Victoria: 136 people currently peeing

World Toilet Day floats some serious health issues

Calgary Stampeders back to Grey Cup with 22-14 win over Winnipeg Blue Bombers

Calgary was favoured to win the 2017 and 2016 Grey Cups, but lost to the Toronto Argonauts and Ottawa Redblacks respectively.

‘A giant step forward’: new $10 bill featuring Viola Desmond to enter circulation

A new $10 banknote featuring Viola Desmond’s portrait will go into circulation, just over 72 years after she was ousted from the whites-only section of a movie theatre in New Glasgow, N.S.

Most Read