Nelson loses snow-clearing appeal, new trial ordered

Taryn Marchi was injured on Baker Street in 2015 and claims negligence by the city

A woman who was injured stepping into a downtown snowbank five years ago has won an appeal of a court decision in her lawsuit against the City of Nelson.

Taryn Marchi, then 28, injured her knee trying to step through a snowbank on the 300 block of Baker Street on Jan. 6, 2015. She was sent to Kootenay Lake Hospital and later transferred to Kelowna.

At the time, the city was working on plowing downtown during a heavy snowfall. Marchi was wearing running shoes and said she thought the snowbank between the street and the sidewalk would be sufficiently packed to cross.

Marchi sued the city, stating it should have left openings in the snowbank to permit safe access between parked cars and the sidewalk, and that this lack of access led to her injury.

At a Supreme Court of B.C. hearing in March 2019, Justice Mark McEwan ruled that Marchi was “the author of her own misfortune” and that the city was not liable.

He said the city cannot be liable for damages if the policies that guide activities like snow clearing were created in good faith and they were followed.

Three judges at the Court of Appeal, in reviewing McEwan’s decision, raised a difference between written policies on one hand and everyday operational decisions that are made in the moment by city crews on the other. They said the judge should have considered the difference.

A person can’t claim damages based on legitimate policies, but if the claim is based on an operational decision, the city might be liable, the Court of Appeal decision states.

There is no city policy about whether to dig passageways through a snowbank between the street and the sidewalk, or whether to work later on a snowy day. That’s an operational decision and the judge should have factored that in, the Court of Appeal said.

The judges also said that, under tort law (the law that governs the awarding of monetary damages for negligence) and the Negligence Act, the possibility that Marchi should have known about the risk does not necessarily absolve the city of liability.

The Court of Appeal has ruled there should be a new trial in the B.C. Supreme Court. A date has not been set.

The city has never denied that Marchi was injured. Before the trial started, the city and Marchi agreed on a potential dollar amount of damages, the details of which are not public. The judge in the new trial will decide what percentage of that amount, if any, to award to Marchi.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Comments are closed

Just Posted

Four members of Nelson and District Women’s Centre board resign

Centre is closed during COVID-19 and is currently hiring an executive director

Reflecting on former Kootenay MLA Ed Conroy’s legacy

Former BC cabinet minister and Kootenay MLA Ed Conroy passed away June 26

Civic Theatre gets $2.7 million to add two more screens

The grant will allow two small theatres to be built in the back of the current auditorium

Salmo RCMP arrest three, seize $15,000

The three adult men have been charged with “Conspiracy to Commit an Offence.”

B.C. records 31 new cases, six deaths over three days due to COVID-19

There are 166 active cases in B.C., 16 people in hospital

96-year-old woman scales B.C. butte with help of family, friends

‘I did as I was told and I enjoyed every minute of it’

Parallel crises: How COVID-19 exacerbated B.C.’s drug overdose emergency

Part 1: Officials say isolation, toxic drug supply, CERB, contributing to crisis

Canadians with disabilities disproportionately hit by COVID-19 pandemic

More than four out of 10 British Columbians aged 70 and up have various disabilities

Camping offers a great pandemic escape, for less money than you might think

But for many first-timers, knowing what to bring can be a challenge

Turbulence in Canadian opinion on airlines COVID-19 response: poll

Thousands of people have beseeched Transport Minister Marc Garneau to compel airlines to issue refunds,

Police issue warning after baby comes across suspected drugs in Kamloops park

The 11-month-old girl’s mother posted photos on social media showing a small plastic bag containing a purple substance

Most Read