Skip to content

LETTER: A story of two Nelson historical landmarks

From reader Bill McDonnell
28419258_web1_220110-KWS-LetterMacdonell-Mount_1

As I watch the deconstruction of the former Mount St. Francis Hospital, while recalling the “stories of former staff of the long-term care facility and the families of those who were cared for or died there” (from Lee Reid’s book, Stories of Mount St. Francis Hospital 1950-2005), I sorrowfully wonder if such tragedy could be repeated.

As a student, from 1966 to 1970, of MSF’s neighbour Notre Dame University, I was new to Nelson and ignorant of the exemplary long-term care of our elderly citizens next door. Fast forward to 2005 and the IHA’s closure of “the Mount.” Although I recall news surrounding its closure under community protest, I didn’t involve myself. So it is with a sense of guilt for my non-action in 2005 that I now regret the loss of valuable services offered by former staff to our most vulnerable, and the demise of a true Nelson historical landmark.

Is there a lesson to learn from the demise of Mount St. Francis Hospital, as related to the Nelson Civic Centre’s future?

I have questioned Nelson City Council, RDCK and the Recreation Commission as to their long-term plan for the Civic Arena as an ice facility. Although they have acknowledged my question, none have provided an answer. Are their plans to close the Civic Centre as an ice facility? Are their plans to repurpose the Civic Centre? Is its fate that of Mount St. Francis?

Nowadays, weighing heavily on many minds are various historical events, some with world-wide ramifications. What, I wonder, are the social lessons to be learned from not inquiring or not engaging? As with the Civic Centre and Mount St. Francis Hospital, do we need to ask more “whys” before it is too late?

Bill McDonnell

Nelson



Bill Metcalfe

About the Author: Bill Metcalfe

I have lived in Nelson since 1994 and worked as a reporter at the Nelson Star since 2015.
Read more