LETTER: An alternate view of colonialism

From reader Charles Jeanes

Feeling secure in my credentials as a progressive, far-out on the political left all my life, a social-justice warrior and anti-war demonstrator as far back as 1968, I’m going to say something that my allies on the left must react against: in 2019, colonialism likely would not be worse for many parts of the world where the British or French once ruled. The regimes in post-colonial lands now are so often atrociously bad.

Had Europeans stayed at peace in Europe, with no great wars in 1914 and 1939, their empires might have evolved, been liberalized by domestic democratic forces back home in European nations, and the development of the colonial lands might have been less deformed than what has happened in the 20th century.

Hong Kong would be fortunate to have British rule still, Pakistan, Egypt, and India perhaps. Many parts of West Africa would be better off if French rule lasted.

The man who argues this most forcefully in English is Niall Ferguson, if you care to research the topic.

Natives of North America are not included in my alternative-history vision, however, since for them being settled by Europeans has been so demonstrably genocidal.

Had empires of Europe never found the western hemisphere, the path of development here could have unfolded in ways no one can imagine. It would not be utopia, but it would be unique and very unlikely to be worse for natives.

Counterfactual history is entertaining, but insubstantial. No one can know the result of a hypothetical. But people of strong views opposed to colonialism act as if they know that colonial rule was never capable of good effects, and that is false.

“The best lack all conviction, the worst are filled with a passionate intensity.” True of our politics now, as when Yeats wrote these words 100 years ago.

Charles Jeanes

Nelson

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Comments are closed

Just Posted

Lost dog swims Columbia River multiple times searching for home

The dog was missing from his Castlegar home for three days.

Traffic finally eases along Arrow Lakes ferry routes

Motorists were stuck for up to six hours in ferry lineups over the weekend

Nelson climbers raise racism awareness with video

Tula and Tosh Sherkat and Rossland director Liam Barnes collaborated on the video

Horrifying video shows near head-on collision on Trans Canada

The video was captured on dash cam along Highway 1

Fraser Valley woman complains of violent RCMP takedown during wellness check

Mounties respond that she was not co-operating during Mental Health Act apprehension

B.C. sees 12 new COVID-19 cases, no new deaths

Three outbreaks exist in health-care settings

COVID-19: B.C. promotes video-activated services card

Mobile app allows easier video identity verification

ICBC to resume road tests in July with priority for rebookings, health-care workers

Tests have been on hold for four months due to COVID-19

Would you take a COVID-19 vaccine? Poll suggests most Canadians say yes

75 per cent of Canadians would agree to take a novel coronavirus vaccine

Budget officer pegs cost of basic income as calls for it grow due to COVID-19

Planned federal spending to date on pandemic-related aid now tops about $174 billion

Sexologist likens face mask debate to condom debate: What can we learn from it?

Society’s approach to condom usage since the 1980s can be applied to face masks today, one expert says

Most Read