LETTER: Dam, pipeline at odds with UN declaration

From reader Sandra Hartline

I was pleased to note from the government’s website that implementing the UN Declaration of the Rights of Indigenous Peoples in B.C. is about ending discrimination, upholding basic human rights and ensuring more economic justice and fairness.

Given the government’s willingness to implement this declaration, I would like to draw attention to two issues: that of the construction of the Site C Dam and the expansion of the Trans Mountain pipeline.

1) In 2014, Premier John Horgan stated in a filmed interview that First Nations in the Peace region of the Site C Dam had entrenched constitutional rights that were going to be violated by this dam.

However, on Dec. 11, 2017, the government announced its decision to complete the dam. Following six months of confidential talks with the B.C. government and BC Hydro aimed at avoiding litigation, the West Moberly First Nations has announced it will proceed with a Site C dam court challenge, saying it infringes on their treaty rights. Apparently, the talks went nowhere.

2) Indigenous groups involved in the court challenge against Trans Mountain are the Tsleil-Waututh and Squamish Nations in Metro Vancouver, the Coldwater Indian Band in Merritt and a coalition of First Nations in the Fraser Valley.

Although the court has ruled that upcoming arguments can only focus on whether the latest round of Indigenous consultation was adequate, the Tsleil-Waututh and three environmental groups sought leave to appeal that ruling in the Supreme Court of Canada, claiming the Federal Court was wrong to refuse to hear arguments about the risk of an oil spill or threats to endangered southern killer whales.

Lastly, when the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples was adopted in 2007, it introduced the right to free, prior and informed consent for Indigenous Peoples. It is one of the fundamental aspects of the UN declaration and is included in six articles. While all six articles are significant, Article 32.1 is of particular interest to the extractive resource sector in Canada:

“States shall consult and co-operate in good faith with the Indigenous peoples concerned through their own representative institutions in order to obtain their free and informed consent prior to the approval of any project affecting their lands or territories and other resources, particularly in connection with the development, utilization or exploitation of mineral, water or other resources.”

If the government of B.C. is indeed implementing this declaration, how is it that we are continuing to build the Site C Dam and expand the Trans Mountain pipeline?

Is this not duplicitous on the part of the government?

It’s not possible to pick and choose. Implementing the declaration means that Indigenous peoples have the right to free, prior and informed consent regarding any utilization or exploitation of resources, including the building of the Site C Dam and expansion of the Trans Mountain pipeline across Indigenous land.

Sandra Hartline


Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

VIDEO: Kootenay Patricks, Montreal Canadiens play to the crowd in Nelson

The charity game was a spectacle from puck drop

City of Nelson creates student opportunity

“We didn’t realize how much we needed this person until we met them.”

Whitewater’s Adam Kuch to compete at Freeride Junior World Championship

Kuch is one of four Canadians competing in his division

GREG SCOTT: Lack of snow threatens Nelson’s winter carnival

In 1970, the Winter Carnival Society was fretting over whether the third annual event would go ahead

Stepping Stones in need of clothing donations

The Nelson shelter is asking for help

Fashion Fridays: The basics you need for your body type

Kim XO, helps to keep you looking good on Fashion Fridays on the Black Press Media Network

Was Bigfoot just spotted on a Washington State webcam?

Sherman Pass is rougly 70 kilometres south of Grand Forks, B.C.

B.C. employer health tax wins ‘paperweight award’ for red tape

Businesses forced to estimate payroll, pay new tax quarterly

VIDEO: Dashcam records near-miss by bad driver near Sooke

Driver crossed four lanes of traffic and back over again, barely missing three other vehicles

New U.S. LNG terminal near northwestern B.C. town proposed

AlaskCAN International LNG wants terminal just over Canadian border, but using B.C gas

Couple wonders who’s in a Cariboo photo that’s been hanging in their home for years

Charles and Lynn Dick believe the image was taken at the 70 Mile Road House

Here’s what Canada is doing to stop the coronavirus from getting in

Health officials are monitoring multiple possible cases in Canada

‘I would not go’ to China says B.C. traveller concerned about coronavirus

Alice Li said she goes to China every other year but would scrap any travel plans

Royal Canadian Legion expels B.C. member for wearing unearned military commendations

‘Stolen valour is stolen service and it’s just totally wrong’

Most Read