LETTER: Is solar garden info deceptive?

Reader Norm Yanke questions the numbers.

Re: “Solar garden over halfway to sales goal,” Nov. 27

This $300,000 or more project won’t make enough power for four average homes.

A Star article from 2012 says Nelson Hydro made a windfall profit of $500,000, all earned from April through August, when lake levels were high. This is the same time almost all annual solar power is also made. During this time the solar garden power, if sold to BC Hydro, would bring $250.

That same article said BC Hydro, who buys our power, didn’t need it. I asked Alex Love, manager of Nelson Hydro to clarify:did they or didn’t they earn $500,000? This makes solar power absolutely worthless worse, it’s a waste of $300,000.

He replied that was a long time ago. It’s 2015; 2012 isn’t a long time ago. He also said he could only remember once whenBC Hydro didn’t buy Nelson Hydro’s excess power.

A BC Utilities Commission submission from Nelson Hydro stated Nelson Hydro makes 28 GWh of extra power annually. To help you understand that number it would be 700 solar gardens worth of annual power. BC Hydro pays less than a penny,actually 0.7 cents/kWh, for Nelson’s excess power. The entire year of solar garden power if sold to BC Hydro wouldn’t bring$400.

It’s clear Nelson Hydro makes a lot of excess power, not always able to be sold, that would result in the cleanest and greenest power we know, waterpower, just spilling over the dam. This makes solar power worthless.

This is supposed to reduce greenhouse gas. How? We are sending the cleanest and greenest power over the dam. Solar actually increases greenhouse gas. They say the solar garden will mitigate winter excess power purchase costs from Fortis, last year $6.4 million. During that time the solar garden power made could be bought from Fortis for less than $500. We pay a lot more for excess power from Fortis than BC Hydro pays for our excess power almost six times more.

They call this an investment and say everyone opting in will get a credit. From what?

The project was to be only $25,000 from Nelson Hydro to get it started and all future costs paid for by those opting in. I asked Mr. Love under whose authority and when this changed. He didn’t answer. Now every Nelson Hydro customer is in for at least half of this project cost. Mr. Love blocked my emails to his staff saying I was wasting their time. I was trying to educate and help.

Do those who bought in know this? Will they proudly display the stickers in their window for every solar panel they bought?Help this city: go ask for your money back.

The solar garden is a political greenwashing feel good waste.

Norm Yanke

Nelson

 

 

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

UPDATED: Lead found in Nelson, Creston and Salmo schools

Fourteen water fountains tested for higher than accepted lead content

UPDATED: Man dies in backcountry near Whitewater Ski Resort

The victim was found unresponsive in a tree well Friday

Small, Little to represent Kootenays at mixed curling provincials

The pair won the regional playdowns last weekend in Trail

Nelson asks RDCK for clarity on recycling costs

City paid $216,217 to collect rural neighbours’ recycling in 2019, wants to see the math

Prominent Slocan Valley environmental activist dies

Marilyn Burgoon was ‘tough and determined’

VIDEO: The Library Rock(s)

Friends and fans of the Nelson library packed the Capitol Theatre Friday to celebrate 100 years

Meng extradition case back in court for second day on double criminality test

Meng is accused of lying to HSBC about Huawei’s relationship with an Iran-based subsidiary

Canada to ratify new NAFTA next week following U.S. Senate approval: Trudeau

Trudeau says millions of Canadians depend on stable, reliable trade

Skier dies at Fernie Alpine Resort

It’s the second person to die in a tree well at a ski resort in B.C. in the past week.

Warm ‘blob’ could be behind mass starvation of North Pacific seabirds: study

Unprecedented death toll raises red flag for North American marine ecosystems

VIDEO: Vancouver Island mom shares ‘insane’ experience of viral dinosaur video

Tabitha Cooper filmed her costumed sons meeting their grandma at the Victoria International Airport

Vancouver Island home to one of Canada’s largest private skateboard collections

Eric Pinto owns hundreds of boards, spanning multiple decades

ICBC to bring in ranking system for collision, glass repair shops

Change comes after the much-maligned auto insurer has faced criticism for sky-high premiums

Most Read