LETTER: Mandatory voting no panacea

From reader Dan Siemens

Re: “Should voting be mandatory in federal elections?

Canada is by nature a peace loving and stable country and citizens who vote reflexively associate that circumstance with the fact we are governed by a democracy.

The existing state of our democracy, though, is an insult to intelligent thinking people.

The article on mandatory voting epitomizes the conflicted nature of those who vote. It stated that the majority of British Columbians favour making voting mandatory while simultaneously reporting that, depending on age, between 72 and 84 per cent of citizens believe “most federal politicians have to follow the party line and have little or no autonomy.” Explain to me how making voting mandatory is going solve this disconnect.

That politicians have no autonomy is more than just a belief, it is fact. Why do parties use a whip except to ensure coerced unanimity? MPs and MLAs are voting pawns of the party, not our representatives. This fact was verified by the 1990 court case of Wall vs. Littlechild where Justice E.A. Marshall ruled that the MPs and MLAs are not accountable to their constituents, only to parliament.

The Star article indicated that North Korea was a country that has mandatory voting, not exactly a country to emulate. Therefore rather than being forced to participate in a meaningless exercise we should demand democratic reforms that would guarantee our vote carries weight.

Dan Siemens


Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Nelson’s American sister city faces COVID-19 culture war

In Sandpoint, Idaho, wearing a mask is about Black Lives Matter, gun rights, and COVID-19

UPDATE: Body of Slocan River drowning victim recovered

The man was swimming near Winlaw on Wednesday.

Nelson’s SMRT1 Technologies to provide vending tech to Vancouver company

UpMeals will launch 22 machines across Canada using SMRT1’s personalized machines

July Kootenay real estate sales at record high

Sales and prices of Kootenay real estate on the rise

Kaslo council says it was overlooked in long-term care announcement

“We’re fed up … They have ignored every attempt we’ve made to contact them”

Canada to match donations to Lebanon relief

Canada is directing all of its aid for this crisis directly to humanitarian organizations, not the Lebanese government

COVID-19 could mean curtains for film and TV extras

Background performers worry they’re being replaced by mannequins on film and TV sets

Laid-off B.C. hotel workers begin hunger strike demanding job protection

Laid-off workers not sure what they’ll do when government support programs end

‘Huckleberry’ the bear killed after B.C. residents admit to leaving garbage out for videos

North Shore Black Bear Society said it was local residents who created a ‘death sentence’ for bear

Researchers find cannabis use in pregnancy linked to greater risk of autism

Researchers caution findings only show association — not cause and effect

Small Manitoba town mourning after well-liked teens killed by tornado

Melita residents feeling profound grief after the deaths of Shayna Barnesky and Carter Tilbury

Antonio Banderas says he’s tested positive for coronavirus

Acclaimed actor celebrating his 60th birthday in quarantine

Bear put down after being found on Vancouver Island kitchen counter

Bear trapped and killed near Ucluelet after repeated instances of entering sheds and homes

Who can dismiss the Governor General? A look at protocols and possibilities

The Governor General is appointed by the Queen, on the advice of the prime minister

Most Read