LETTER: Opposed to Site C dam

I am very concerned that the federal government could soon approve the construction of the Site C dam in the Peace Valley.

I am very concerned that the federal government could soon approve the construction of the Site C dam in the Peace Valley.

The Peace is a long way from here, but I know that Kootenay residents will relate to some of the major concerns with this project: the destruction of critical farmland, the impacts to First Nations cultural practices, loss of wildlife habitat including wetlands, and the negative impacts on our climate.

The proposed Site C dam threatens to flood over 100 square kilometres of rich valley-bottom lands, including farmland, wildlife habitat, First Nations cultural sites and heritage sites. The reservoir from Site C would cause the destruction of 6,000 hectares of Peace Valley farmland — resulting in the biggest loss from the Agricultural Land Reserve in its entire 40-year history.

First Nations in the region oppose Site C, and the federal-provincial Joint Review Panel that reviewed the project acknowledged that the project poses a “significant adverse effect” on traditional uses of the land by First Nations, some of which “cannot be mitigated.”

The panel’s other conclusions acknowledge “significant adverse effects on fish and fish habitat,” significant effects on at-risk and sensitive ecological communities and “a significant adverse effect on wetlands.”

Site C would increase annual greenhouse gas emissions in British Columbia by almost 150,000 tonnes. The project’s carbon footprint derives from construction emissions, as well as emissions created by the flooded boreal forest as it decays.

For what? British Columbians may need or want more electricity in the future, but there are better ways to meet our energy needs than destroying our farmland. The panel concluded that: “the Proponent has not fully demonstrated the need for the project on the timetable set forth.”

Some analysts believe that the power from Site C would be used to power the burgeoning gas fracking (hydraulic fracturing) industry. Site C is located above the Montney Formation, the largest shale gas deposit in BC.

It’s worth noting that the Nova Scotia government is banning fracking due to environmental concerns.

In addition, the panel report suggests that the $8 billion price tag that BC Hydro posits for Site C may not be accurate, and recommends oversight by the province’s utility watchdog, the BC Utilities Commission.

That’s at least $8 billion in taxpayer dollars, to build a highly destructive project that we don’t need. Meanwhile an economic study commissioned by the David Suzuki Foundation found that the ecological services provided by farmland and nature in the Peace River watershed are conservatively worth an estimated $7.9 billion to $8.6 billion a year.

Now is the time to stop this project once and for all. I urge readers to write to the BC and federal governments expressing your opposition to the Site C dam.

Candace Batycki


Just Posted

RDCK calls for reversal of Sinixt extinction

The board opposed a land transfer to the Westbank First Nation this week

Nelson city council to update banner policy

Council will revisit the wording of the policy at its December meeting

Forecasters promote avalanche safety awareness

Avalanche Canada advising backcountry enthusiasts to get proper training and equipment.

Meteorite fragments found near Crawford Bay

The pieces came from the fireball that exploded over Kootenay Lake in September

Nelson honours veterans on Remembrance Day

About 200 people gathered at Nelson’s cenotaph on Saturday to pay their respects to Canada’s veterans

VIDEO: Rare comic showing Superman’s 1st appearance to be auctioned

The 1938 comic features Superman hoisting a car over his head

Man pleads guilty to Leafs recycling depot theft

Dezmond Waggoner had been charged with theft over $5,000

Nelson Leafs stretch winning streak to six

Jack Karran scored twice in the Leafs 6-3 win over Fernie

Nelson city hall selling bear-proof garbage bins

The city has purchased 100 bins and is charging residents $205

COLUMN: Will West Kootenay forests survive?

As with most things around ecology, the answer is not simple, says columnist Greg Utzig

Julien Locke races to NST World Cup berth

Black Jack cross-country skier Julien Locke races to first place at World Cup qualifier

B.C. sport groups to address child sex abuse in sports

viaSport is organizing a full day of education in association with Canadian Centre for Child Protection and the Coaching Association of Canada.

Most Read