LETTER: Questioning importance of class sizes

Regardless of what the courts say, I believe it common sense that the ability to determine class size be a management responsibility.

The call from teachers in the current labour dispute that class size should be a teacher factor in contracts is nothing but a grab for leverage to maintain jobs for teachers  when enrollments, upon which funding is largely based, are dropping.

Regardless of what the courts say, I believe it common sense that the ability to determine class size always be  a management responsibility which properly belongs to school boards.

While a small class size may seem nice to parents, it is not if it doubles the provincial salary budget of teachers when other demands on the public purse are just as pressing.

I have a picture of my Grade 6 class at Herbert Spencer Elementary School in  New Westminster.  The year was 1941. A count of this class size results in something over 40 students.

As I recall we had our fair share of slower learners who would probably be called “special education” now. And we had some in the middle and several very bright kids.

In this class there are some who became doctors, several lawyers, scientists, athletes and a politician or two (who were probably also lawyers). I have often been accused of mispronouncing that by calling them “liars.” One became a senator but he seems to have been absent when the picture was taken.

Once I was interviewing a candidate for a fairly senior position.  He had a doctorate in education.  On reviewing his dissertation I realized that after all the pages and pages of data and argument his thesis seemed to be that “smart kids get good marks.”

Another way of putting it might be that regardless of what you do to the education system the bright kids will get by. The more you water down the content in the interests of socialization (i.e moving kids ahead in grade no matter how poor their marks) learning by absorption, the less the average kids will take away in real learning.

And I believe it is the same now as it was when we old crocks were in school: it takes study, self-discipline and hard work for most of us to do well in school, not our social popularity or what passes now  as knowledge that somehow our kids are expected to get by absorption.

Perhaps by  sleeping with a text book? Perhaps no matter what they do now many graduates will leave the schools unable to calculate a percentage or submit a grammatical and properly spelled  employment letter.

Or even worse, unable to meet the requirements of university or technological training. In many ways I am glad that my own kids are long past their school days and approaching or in retirement and that there are other options for their grandchildren: independent schools, home schooling, distant education and yes, perhaps a revitalized public school system.

Perhaps, in other words, the teacher has less learning impact than hard work, motivation and the brains with which a kid is blessed. Perhaps we need a viable tool to measure teachers’ performance in how well they do their job.


M.A. Rhodes

Just Posted

Site C protest held outside Michelle Mungall’s office

The demonstration Wednesday was held following the NDP’s decision to continue the project

Readers light up social media over Christmas lights

Star website and Facebook page flooded with comments

PHOTOS: CP holiday train stops in Nelson

On Tuesday the CP holiday train made its 19th annual stop in Nelson

Special citation for cultural icon

Stephanie Fischer is ‘a true friend’ of Nelson

Where are Nelson’s downtown Christmas lights?

People have been voicing their complaints to the Star about this, so we decided to look into it

VIDEO: Average Canadian food bill to rise by $348 in 2018

Atlantic Canada and B.C. will see the most increases for consumers

L.V. Rogers finishes 14th at volleyball provincials

The senior girls struggled during play earlier this month

Nelson’s SEEDS to move from Lakeside Park

New gardening location will be at Seventh Street Park

Columnist, dance instructor honoured by city

A Nelson Star columnist and a creative dance leader receive awards

Grease auditions set for the Capitol

Black productions is bringing 50s musical to town.

Breakfast gives kids a big boost

Books, toys and cash donated

Poverty the featured topic at artistic event

Artists to perform at event organized by Nelson at its Best

Local fabric artist Kate Bridger opens exhibit at Nelson Public Library

Bridger will be exhibited at the Nelson Public Library until Dec. 31

Family doctors should learn to treat addiction, not shun patients: scientist

B.C. Centre on Substance Use’s Dr. Evan Wood said efforts underway to change addiction medicine image

Most Read