LETTER: Solar garden figures dubious

Kevin LePape says Nelson Hydro's proposed solar project understates the likely costs.

Re: “Solar Garden over halfway to sales goal”

This article has been corrected from “Proctor explained the choice of Nelson Hydro’s site at Bonnington is based on data collected from sensors placed there” to now read that “Proctor explained the choice of Nelson Hydro’s site at Bonnington is based on data collected from sensors on Elephant Mountain and at Lakeside since June 2014, and with a pathfinder measurement that is used to measure the effect of the horizon on the amount of sun available at a site, combined with long-term weather data from the Nelson airport.”

Right, let me clarify: incomplete data from a different location was extrapolated to simulate data for Bonnington. So in other words, no actual data was collected at the Bonnington site. What I said.

Much more important is the other erroneous statement attributed to Ms. Proctor: “Proctor said beyond a contribution by Nelson Hydro of $25,000 with an additional $2,000 per year for maintenance, the project is intended to be financially self-supporting …” This is pure horse pucky.

The maintenance of $2,000 per year is hugely understated as it equates to about five to eight hours per year for Nelson Hydro personnel. In order to keep panels clear of snow and ice (and clean from the ubiquitous dust we are all familiar with that coats everything here in the summer months), keep the site from becoming overgrown, to provide security and perform inspections through the year will cost double or more than is being allowed for.

Then there is the cost of inevitable, non-warranty failures of components such as the micro-inverters which have a finite, usually 10-year service life. The equipment is to be completely owned by Nelson Hydro and therefore any replacement and upkeep will be paid for by Nelson Hydro which means all of us and our Nelson Hydro rates.

How was the quoted figure of $50,000 ($2,000 per year) arrived at? I have asked this question directly and have yet to receive any answer or see any explanation anywhere. I expect that the maintenance and repair over the life of the project will easily exceed $100,000 and it is likely that the people not buying into the Solar Garden will end up paying more than the people who do.

Of course, this is the way with solar in this part of the world. It just makes no sense. The Kimberly SunMine is a farce that only flew because Teck paid for more than half of it. In Nelson someone else is paying for more than half the Solar Garden but the people paying haven’t been told by the people taking the money.

Kevin LePape, Rural Nelson

Just Posted

Tailings site near Salmo could be remediated

The tailings came from the historic Jersey-Emerald mine

Greyhound service cuts decision expected next week

Nelson could see its bus service reduced on Wednesday

Nelson to review city council pay levels

The results would apply to the next council following the municipal election this fall

Petition: reinstate band program at Mt. Sentinel

SD8 superintendent is surveying Slocan Valley students to gauge interest

Logging planned for Cottonwood Lake and Apex areas

The private land to be logged is owned by Nelson Land Corporation headed by Mike Jenks

What it means to be human (without a smartphone)

Two LVR teachers take control of phones in the classroom

Nelson Leafs fall to Rebels 4-1

The Leafs open the playoffs next weekend

Nelson speedskater wins two races

Ian Walgren was on the podium at a Special Olympics event

Nelson Nordic Ski Club hosts two races

The Clearwater Challenge and Kootenay Cup both ran last weekend

Five gold medals at provincials for Nelson Boxing Club

Local fighters put on a clinic last weekend

COLUMN: Love in the pages – and on the plate

Check This Out with Anne DeGrace

LETTER: Cannabis Compassion Club optimistic in legal battle with city

The downtown non-profit has been operating since 2000

VIDEO: Protesters rally for affordable housing ahead of B.C. budget

Residents call on province to keep locals housed

#Metoo movement causing confusion in many men, fear of missteps with women: experts

Being painted by the same sweeping brush as those alleged to have mistreated women has angered men

Most Read