LETTER: Tax free savings accounts lack fairness

From reader Rod Retzlaff

It’s tax time again, and as we all know every government since Adam and Eve have promised their charges that they would establish a “fair” taxing system. In Canada we largely tax labour, either by taxing workers directly, or by taxing goods and services provided by labour. So we really do double down on taxing workers. We all know that people with a lot of money manage to make much more money, not by working themselves but by manipulating those of us who are short on funds and need to work to survive.

The Harper government came up with a grand scheme to make taxes fairer for everyone by allowing people to put some of their money in a tax free savings account. The money in that account, and any profits derived from investing that money would remain untaxable. So we were all allowed to put aside $5,000 per tax year. That made it fair, right? Now I know many can easily afford to save $5,000 per year, but I also know there are a few who simply cannot afford to do so. The TFSA works great for those who can afford it. Currently anyone who has been paying taxes for the last 14 years is allowed to put away up to $70,000.

Now if, say, 20 million Canadians did so, there would be, and could be, a pool of $1.4 trillion available for investment in this country that wouldn’t earn a dime in tax revenue for Canada. That is assuming that all the investments were flat and did not grow over the last 14 years, which seems highly unlikely. The Tories tried to double the TFSA amount to $10,000, but that failed to win them the election, and the Liberals wisely stuck with the original $5,000.

Now the Liberals are raising the TFSA limit to $5,500.

So the people who work and produce something can pay taxes through the nose for earning their money by doing so, and investors can sit on their arses infinitely making money and never pay any tax on their investment gains.

TFSAs might be good for some but they are crippling our government when it comes to taxing investment gains, and forcing us to go in debt to provide the services that Canadians need. This is a ridiculous plan and the longer it continues, the worse it will get.

Rod Retzlaff

Glade

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Kootenay program encourages gardeners to share what they grow during pandemic

The West Kootenay Permaculture Co-op is sending out free seeds, but with a catch

Nelson and COVID-19: everything you need to know

Check this page for every local story related to the outbreak

West Kootenay residents stranded in Peru seek a way home

Three West Kootenay residents are in remote places, unable to get to Lima’s international airport

PHOTOS: Neighbourhood stroll during a pandemic

Jackie Zelt went looking for people in a time of isolation

West Kootenay couple escapes Spain – safe, sound, and in self-isolation

BC couple Garrett Kucher and Tory Apostoliuk make it home after almost a week of lockdown in Spain

B.C. records first at-home death from COVID-19, but 70+ hospital patients have recovered

Total of 970 novel coronavirus cases in B.C., with the majority in the Lower Mainland area

Helping those at risk, one piece of paper at a time through ‘isolation communication’

Simple paper tool during pandemic making its way across Canada thanks to social media.

‘Back to school, in a virtual way’ for B.C. students in COVID-19 pandemic

Province adds online resources to help parents at home

Canadian COVID-19 round-up: Air Canada cuts 15,000 jobs, 90% of flights

Comprehensive Canadian news update as of 2:30 p.m., Monday, March 30.

Apartments evacuated during police stand-off

The incident occurred at Grand Forks apartment building on March 28

Canada expands 75% wage subsidy to COVID-19 affected businesses of all sizes: Trudeau

Program will provide up to $847 per week for each worker

Pay parking suspended at B.C. hospitals due to COVID-19

Temporary free parking reduces need for keypads, contact

Canadian ferry operators call for inclusion in COVID-19 travel restrictions

Domestic travel restrictions should include ferries, operators say

Most Read