LETTER: The consequences of closing Trafalgar

I am feeling quite upset and frustrated with the school board’s decision to close schools in our district.

Re: “Parents plead for Winlaw, W.E. Graham, Jewett”

As a parent, teacher and concerned member of society, I am feeling quite upset and frustrated with the school board’s decision to close schools in our district. An article in last week’s Star stated Trafagar’s PAC has accepted the closure of Trafalgar. I don’t believe that all parents have “accepted” the closure of Trafalgar Middle School.

Not all parents are happy with Trafalgar’s anticipated closure. Teachers are not all unanimously happy with Grade 6s and 7s moving into the K-5 elementary schools. Specialist teachers are mourning the demise of those specialized classes: band, drama, shop, cooking, outdoor rec, all the classes that kids have had a choice in taking in middle school.

Don’t be fooled; these are not classes that can easily or at all be implemented in an elementary setting. Not all parents are happy their kids are staying back in elementary schools. I can’t imagine parents are happy that their kids will lose the opportunity to take specialized classes in a middle school setting, therefore our students in this district will not be receiving the kind of education that they deserve.

Parents of young elementary children: Have you thought about what the Trafalgar closure will mean for your young child in two years? Your elementary school will be full to bursting with no rooms for grade group learning, likely no fine arts classroom, and older kids in the school creating an entirely different ambience in the school, not to mention at recess time.

Parents of Grade 8-12 students in a couple of years: Do you realize there was nothing in the budget talks about adding onto LVR? No new lockers, no new rooms, bathrooms, not even portables. What is going to happen to my child who will be in Grade 9 when all this supposedly comes down? It makes me sick to see her education getting worse and worse and it seems that no one on our school board is standing up for her and the hundreds of other students who will suffer from this short sighted closure.

Finally, parents, there is no guarantee that there will be a rebuild of South Nelson. The government will gladly take the $24 million that our school board is so diligently saving for them, and they will not likely give our board $11 million to rebuild South Nelson. They will give it to the coastal schools for seismic upgrades, and to Surrey with their exploding student population. Perhaps that is why our school board wants to put an English track K-7 at Central school, because they know that the chance of a South Nelson rebuild is not good, and that way there will be a school in uphill when South Nelson closes.

I’ve taught in K-5, K-6, K-7, 6-8, 7-9, 7-12, 8-12 and 9-12 schools, so I do have a bit of experience in what goes on. Grade 7s are big kids. The rooms in most elementary schools can’t properly accommodate Grade 7s. It can be argued that years ago there were Grade 7s at Hume School; but one begs to ask the question: Why were they moved up to a middle school? Because at that age, the best practice for those students is changing teachers, changing classrooms, specialized classes, and a transition time before high school.

What is happening in our district is not the best thing for our students; it is happening because according to law, our school board has to balance a budget (or they are fired), and they are closing schools to balance it. It’s too bad that they feel that they can’t follow the brave lead of the Vancouver School Board, and stand up to this government, which has seen over 250 schools close over the last fifteen years because of this government’s inefficiency in long term planning and continued underfunding of our public education system.

What if, just, what if, all the school boards in BC stood up to this government which has over the last 15 years, systematically destroyed our public school system?

Lisa Backus, Nelson

 

Just Posted

5 tips for talking to your kids about cannabis

Health officials recommend sharing a harm reduction-related message.

Voters pack Nelson mayoral forum

Candidates answered questions from journalist Glenn Hicks

EDITORIAL: Nelson mayor’s race uninspiring

An incumbent mayor, a former mayor and a clown walk into a forum

Nelson downtown holiday lighting by mid November, city says

But for this year, only on the 400 block of Baker Street

COLUMN: What Wayne Stetski did on his summer vacation

The Kootenay-Columbia MP talks cimate change, farmers markets and Bill C-281

VIDEO: Monday Roundup!

Elections stuff, youth homelessness, WEED!

Private marijuana stores should shut down, Mike Farnworth says

B.C. has approved 62 licences, but they still need local approval

HPV vaccine does not lead to riskier sex among teen girls: UBC

Girls are less likely to have sex now than they were a decade ago

Koreas agree to break ground on inter-Korean railroad

The rival Koreas are holding high-level talks Monday to discuss further engagement amid a global diplomatic push to resolve the nuclear standoff with North Korea.

Flash floods kill at least 7 people in southwest France

Flash floods have left several people dead in southwest France, with roads swept away and streams become raging torrents as the equivalent of several months of rain fell overnight, authorities said Monday.

Trump to visit Florida, Georgia; search ongoing for missing

The death toll from Michael’s destructive march from Florida to Virginia stood at 17.

Canadians widely unaware of accomplishments of famous women, poll suggests

A new poll suggests Canadians have a lot to learn about the accomplishments of some of the country’s most famous women.

Temporary access allowed for residents of landslide-threatened B.C. community

The district says areas of access to the community of about 54 homes could be expanded, depending on advice from a geotechnical engineer.

Joint inspection planned for missing journalist at Saudi Consulate

Turkish officials have said they fear a Saudi hit team killed and dismembered Washington Potst reporter Jamal Khashoggi

Most Read