LETTERS: For and against proportional representation

From readers Maurice Rhodes and Ann Remnant

Re: “Against proportional representation” (Letters, Nov. 8)

Recently Mr Rod Retzlaff of Glade recently made several excellent points in your paper against proposed voting alternatives and for the system we have, sometimes called “first past the post.”

I support him in his views and would but add that our present system meets the requirements of democracy: that interested persons, and those who might agree with him or her, are free to nominate and support that person as a candidate for a position in a legislature that operates according to a constitution and the laws of the state.

I am free to enter a voting booth (or not) and secretly choose whom among the candidates I favour. Then I am free to leave the polling place with with my vote still secret and no threat or censure me for how I voted.

The fact that some people did not see the person they voted for elected should not give them the right to a second choice in the hope they might get their cake and eat it too. They claim they have no voice but the winning candidate represents them too in a representative democracy. We are not like wolves at the kill who, because they were in the chase, demand to have a go at the carcass.

Maurice A. Rhodes


Re: “Against proportional representation” (Letters, Nov. 8)

Rod Retzlaff warns that changing our voting system to proportional representation (PR) could spell the end of local representation and result in an avalanche of small parties. Neither Rod, nor I, nor anybody else I know wants all our future MLAs to be lawyers from Vancouver, nor do we want our future governments to be handicapped by a multitude of micro parties.

It’s true that B.C. voters place a high value on having a local MLA who lives in and understands the region they represent. In such a large and diverse province as ours, nothing else makes sense.

Fortunately, there are many PR systems that offer both local representation and good proportionality.

Nor would either of us welcome an avalanche of small parties. New Zealand, a former British colony that inherited the first past the post (FPTP) system, like Canada, switched to a proportional system after a referendum in 1993.

Their chosen system guarantees representation from all corners of the country, reflects NZ’s diverse population and keeps the government stable. After NZ’s most recent election, three large stable parties make up the government, with a grand total of five parties elected to parliament.

After 24 years of PR, not much of an avalanche.

FPTP makes a mockery of our democracy. Last election, thousands of Liberal, NDP and Greens voters, 49.5 per cent of B.C. voters, elected absolutely no one.

FPTP also creates an adversarial environment where parties focus on scoring political points rather than looking for solutions. PR better represents the public will, builds on co-operation and collaboration between parties and leads to better decisions which benefit us all.

Mr. Retzlaff is right when he says that FPTP elections have winners and losers, what he fails to see is that it is us voters who are the losers. B.C. is a great place to live and we are largely hard working, honest people.

Why would a nice province like ours want to hang out with a power grubbing system like FPTP, when we could have a system that ensures that our vote will count, and our neighbour’s vote will count too?

Ann Remnant


Just Posted

Liberals’ Kootenay-Columbia candidate stands by Trudeau despite scandal

Robin Goldsbury says the prime minister’s racist photo is a learning opportunity

Kootenay-Columbia incumbent MP responds to Trudeau brownface scandal

Stetski proud of NDP leader Singh’s reaction, which focused on people not power

Inclusive Employer Award goes to local landscaper

Chris Holt hires people with special needs to do garden maintenance

UPDATED: Man pleads guilty in Baker Street death

Miles Halverson is guilty of manslaughter in the death of Matt Reeder

VIDEO: Trudeau asks Canada to look to current, not past, actions on race

Liberal leader says he never spoke about the racist photo because he was embarrassed

‘Really disturbing:’ Trudeau’s racist photos worry B.C. First Nation chief

Wet’suwet’en Chief concerned the photos will sow fear in Indigenous communities

‘Unacceptable’: What politicians have to say about Trudeau in blackface

Calgary Mayor Naheed Nenshi: ‘When I saw that picture last night, certainly it was a sucker-punch’

‘He’s trying to kill me’: Victoria police commandeer boats to reach screaming woman

No charges laid and civilians to be awarded honours after incident on Gorge Waterway

VIDEO: B.C. man accused of assaulting sex worker loses temper in interrogation

Defence lawyer says statements made by accused Curtis Sagmoen should be deemed inadmissible

John Horgan promises action after fatal mid-Island bus crash

Premier cites students, local Indigneous community as reason to repair the road

Teens charged in stabbing death of B.C. man in strip mall parking lot

Two youths, aged 15 and 16, charged in Aug. 16 killing of South Surrey’s Paul Prestbakmo

Forestry watchdog warned B.C. government about Bamfield Road in 2008

Ombusman’s specific concerns re-surface in wake of bus crash that killed two students

Photos surface of Conservative candidate at B.C. event with people in blackface

The controversial “Black Peter” character has been a feature at Sinterklaas celebrations

Most Read