Protectionism won’t work for Nelson

Restricting trade in fact hurts not only the community at large

The recent article on the proposed EU trade treaty appears to suggest there’s a universally held belief in City Hall that “buying local” is a good thing and something to be fought for. Proponents seem oblivious to the reality that restricting trade not only benefits mainly those who produce over-priced and inferior products, but creates barriers between people, with impact far beyond our own community.

This is not to suggest that local businesses, tradespeople, professionals and artists are incapable of world-class work — one has only to attend a few concerts, just as an example, to realize this — only that absent the competition in the market place, there is virtually no way of determining this nor the incentive to prove it. This problem is exacerbated in a smaller market where many goods and services have a single source, the quality of which is very difficult to determine in a closed market. Think Lada.

Further proof, if it is really required, of the fallacy of this thinking is a consideration of the relative wealth of countries that are open to trade. The ultimate closed country is undoubtedly North Korea, where starvation is practically a national policy. And the “open” countries? Contrary to what people often think, they are not solely, or even mostly, the resource-rich countries. They are the Singapores, the Switzerlands, the Hong Kongs, the Hollands (to say nothing of the Japans!) — countries that have had virtually no choice but to do things better.

Restricting trade in fact hurts not only the community at large, but does a great disservice to the exceptional talents among us. Aside from encouraging a culture of mediocrity here at home, building trade barriers, ironically, results in others doing likewise, with a proportionally greater impact on the talented of the community.

As bad as the economic impact of isolationism is, it is unfortunately not the only negative consequence. Just as bad is its impact on international relations and, for lack of a better term, the brotherhood of man. There is, in protectionism, an implicit “us-you” mentality that is the last thing the world needs these days. How such a view resonates so strongly with the left of centre in this country — the chief proponents of trade restrictions — is difficult to understand.

Because it affects all of the community, hopefully city council will look beyond the apparent groundswell for protectionism and open this discussion to the community.

Dave Haynes

Nelson

 

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Jumbo Valley to be protected, ending decades-long dispute over proposed ski resort

Development rights permanently retired for site of proposed year-round ski resort west of Invermere

Nelson Leafs lose to Dynamiters 4-3 in overtime

The game got off to a bizarre start early in the first period

On the job hunt with Nelson’s Make A Change Canada

The employment charity is organizing next week’s Kootenay Patricks, Montreal Canadiens game

FedEx distribution centre coming to Castlegar

Development permit for ground facility before council next week.

Heart, minds, and 100 years of the Nelson library

Past and future collide this year at the Nelson library, and it all kicks off this weekend

Kids across Canada more at risk of hospitalization from flu this season: doctor

Dr. Theresa Tam said influenza B does not usually peak until February or later

Closed mills, housing surge support a positive forecast for lumber industries

B.C. lumber producers have closed mills accounting for 18% of province’s capacity, RBC report says

Good Samaritan pays part of rent for B.C. woman facing eviction in can-collecting dispute

Zora Hlevnjak, 76, supplements her pension by collecting cans and receiving public donations

Kelowna’s ‘Baby Mary’ finds biological parents after more than 30 years

Geneologist and DNA test helped her connect with her biological parents

Kelowna hotel to award couples for baby-making with Nooner deal

The deal includes a free stay every Valentine’s Day for the next 18 years

‘Scariest boat ride of my life’: Passengers trapped by ice on rocky B.C. ferry sailing

The Nimpkish docked in Bella Coola on Jan.12 coated in a thick layer of ice

B.C. pair ordered to pay $55,000 for oil tank discovered four years after selling home

Judge says defendants breached contract, despite being unaware of tank until basement flooded

Canada to give $25,000 to families of each Canadian who died in Iran plane crash

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau also made it clear that Canada still expects Iran to compensate victims

Oil and gas industry applauds top court’s dismissal of B.C.’s Trans Mountain case

The high court’s ruling Thursday removes one of the remaining obstacles for the project

Most Read