Replacing one imperfect system with another

Proportional representation has its flaws.

Readers have been subjected to numerous writers extolling the advantages of proportional representation. The reality is that they are pushing to change an imperfect system for another imperfect system. A recent writer harkened to a past minority government that he believed had to listen and/or work with another party that supposedly hastened the introduction of medicare and other social innovations. Ironically, the writer reverses course and says this is why we should change the electoral system. Yet, obviously this small example showed how our present first past the post system works.

Similar writers lament citizen participation in the present electoral process, yet there is no proof that other systems have substantially higher voter engagement, especially for those who belong to no particular special interest party that is the essence of many proportional representation systems.

Activists being activists, they will always find fault with the system that denies them power. Interestingly, they push a more “democratic” agenda, I wonder if it is the same more democratic agenda that Maduro and his cronies have sprung on the Venezuelan people, who have shed lots of blood to oppose that hijacking in word and action of what we previously deemed a fairly understandable term.

Recently another pro letter to the editor, had the temerity to say the present system distorts politics. Yet if one were to canvass those countries that have adapted pro/rep, political distortion is the underlying modus operandi of all those civil societies. Couched amongst his lofty words we see clearly the underlying theme that if it isn’t his definition of democracy, then it doesn’t have much currency. Almost everything he lambasted about our present system is also true of the pro rep system.

Yet, now we have an unelected premier and unelected ruling coalition that is going to force us to change the way we elect our government. They are stacking the deck to ensure their “democratic” vision is the way forward. But success for them does not mean success for the rest of us.

Jeff Shecter


Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

PHOTOS: Nelson joins protests against racism, police brutality

The protest was similar to those being held throughout Canada and the United States

Game on? Nelson sports organizations wait and see

Nelson Baseball Association has already scrapped its season

RCMP: 93% of inspected boats on Kootenay Lake don’t have safety equipment

Weekend inspections found a high number of boats that don’t comply with national regulations

Temporary rail trail detour will allow upgrade to Nelson’s water source

City will be laying a water line between Stanley Street and Mountain Station parking lot

Water quality advisory issued for Nelson

Run-off has created a high level of turbidity in the city’s drinking water

VIDEO: A Vancouver Island black bear takes weekend nap in eagle tree

Videos captured by Terry Eissfeldt shows the bear arriving Saturday night and sleeping in on Sunday

Help the Nelson Star continue its mission to provide trusted local news

Black Press is now accepting donations to keep its papers operating

189 homes in Grand Forks area given evacuation orders

Homes are in the Nursery, Grand Forks Airport, Gilpin Rd., Johnson Flats and Granby Rd. areas

George Floyd asphyxiated by sustained pressure: family autopsy

Death sparked a wave of protests across the U.S. and abroad

COVID-19: B.C. commercial landlords can’t evict if they decline rent assistance

Emergency order ‘incentive’ for federal program, Carole James says

Investigators probe death of CN employee at Surrey rail yard

Transportation Safety Board is investigating an ‘occurrence that took place during switching operations’

Trans Mountain starts B.C. leg of pipeline twinning project

Mostly finished in Alberta, Burnaby terminal expanding

NDP getting COVID-19 wage subsidy ‘indirectly,’ B.C. Liberal leader says

Andrew Wilkinson says he’s heard no concerns from public

Most Read