Rowling part of modern decay

Fill in the blank from this quote, in a J.K. Rowling Harry Potter novel: “Words are our most inexhaustible source of m_____.”

Fill in the blank from this quote, in a J.K. Rowling Harry Potter novel: “Words are our most inexhaustible source of m_____.”

The word is magic. But if you thought money, you could be excused. Rowling got wealthy as the creator of the Harry Potter fantasy series and all its spin-off products and profits. She is the mistress of writing to get rich by expanding some pretty thin ideas into very thick books.

I’ve just seen the last (thankfully) of the Potter films. I do not think highly of Rowling’s books; I much admire J.R.R.Tolkien however. The differences between them grew out of their mental universes and cultural roots. Rowling is doomed to be shallow by her own lack of mental furnishings, whereas Tolkien had enormous depths of mind from his profound knowledge of history, philology, and the deep traditions of his catholic christian faith. I do not wish to dump on Potter fans’ enthusiasm or maturity, but let’s have some literary perspective.

Tolkien fought in WWI trenches, where many of his friends died, and served the British war effort against Hitler, experiences of depth such that Rowling would not approach in her easier life.

Pottermania is a children’s phenomenon; Rowling wrote for young people. Tolkien’s Ring books are for adults. Mind you, sociologists and psychologists these days recognize that adulthood is delayed, in particular for males in rich nations’ societies; thus males up to 30 years old profess to Pottermania.

English readers, polled for their opinion of the greatest English work of fiction in the 20th century, have chosen Tolkien. Rowling cannot make that kind of impact, nor does she deserve to. It’s nice that ‘tweens, teens and unmatured adults like tales of English boarding school and eccentric magicians, but they will get nothing of profundity from Rowling. Tolkien, and his friend C. S. Lewis, will give readers that. Maybe Rowling is perfect for our age of hockey riots, the wars of civilization Canada wages in Libya and Afghanistan, and the daily murder of species by human causes, that we call the modern era.

I’ll end up sounding like a curmudgeon here, but the fact is our age of electronic over-stimulation and hyper-affluence is not productive of a culture that makes us think too hard. Books are hard, screens are easy and fun, and Rowling has garnered praise just for the fact that her books make kids like reading. To provoke deep thought or insights into the human condition asks too much from Potter.

Charles Jeanes



Just Posted

Harrop II launched on Kootenay Lake

The new cable ferry, assembled at Kaslo, is now carrying vehicles between Harrop and Longbeach

Nelson council gets first look at parking survey results

903 residents answered questions about downtown parking and how to improve it

Water advisory issued for South Slocan

Tests have found water quality to be only fair due to turbidity

Selkirk College to make pitch for new student housing on campus

$25 million project would see new student housing built in Nelson, Castlegar

VIDEO: 13-year-old killed in B.C. crash that involved five kids

The children range in age from six to 17.

In a fight against cancer, Victoria man’s only stem cell match was his own donation

More mixed race and Asian stem cell donors needed, says Victoria family

MPs denounce leaked reports of Trudeau-JWR clash over Supreme Court pick

Opposition MPs called the leaks an act of desperation meant to smear Wilson-Raybould

Study says B.C.’s housing policies mean drug users can be targeted for eviction

The study involves 50 people living in Vancouver’s Downtown Eastside

VIDEO: Homicide team called in after three killed in Surrey car crash

Investigators ask public to come forward with information, dashcam video

Stranger climbs onto B.C. family’s second-floor balcony, lights fire in barbecue

Incident in Abbotsford terrifies family with two-year-old boy

Coroner’s inquest announced for Victoria teen’s overdose death

Elliot Eurchuk was 16 years old when he died of an opioid overdose at his Oak Bay home

UPDATED: Sailings resume after BC Ferries boat hits Langdale terminal

The Queen of Surrey is stuck on the dock, causing delays to Horseshoe Bay trips

Eviction halted for B.C. woman deemed ‘too young’ for seniors’ home

Zoe Nagler, 46, had been given notice after living in the seniors complex in Comox for six years

Most Read