The idea is nothing new

Your editorial callsAtamanenko’s private member bill “not a very good idea.” I beg to differ.

Re: “Why pay for the military?” December 2

Your editorial calls Alex Atamanenko’s private member bill giving Canadians the option to redirect military taxes towards peace education and research “not a very good idea.” I beg to differ.

Canada has respected conscientious objection to military service on religious grounds since 1793. During times of military conscription, our government respected the right of conscientious objectors to refuse to kill and exempted them from military service.

There are also Canadian precedents for recognizing conscientious objections to paying for the military. For example, in 1841, objectors to militia tax were allowed to redirect these taxes to public works. In both world wars, objectors to war bonds were allowed to buy a special series of government bonds (peace bonds) whose proceeds were used only for the relief of suffering caused by war.

In all these cases, provisions for objectors in Canadian law have not led to a flood of other groups requesting similar treatment.

Since modern wars are hugely dependent on tax monies, personal refusal to fight is not enough to absolve us from the responsibility of killing.

In fact, in 1981, Senator Eugene Forsey and six other MPs said, “In times of military conscription, exemption from service in the military can be claimed on grounds of conscience, and alternate service is approved. It should be equally possible to claim exemption from taxes intended for war preparation and a related alternative should be offered.” Our Charter of Rights enshrined freedom of conscience based on secular morality as well as religion the following year.

Each year since, a private member’s objectors bill such as Alex’s has been introduced to Parliament to ask the government to respect Freedom of Conscience and Religion and provide a legal alternative for those who are conscientiously opposed to killing and war.

Until a conscientious objector bill is passed into legislation, Conscience Canada provides a positive alternative. For some years now I have diverted the military portion of my taxes into Conscience Canada’s Peace Tax Fund. I encourage you to do so too. More information, including an informational DVD as well as 2012 Peace Tax Return, is available at

Irene Mock



Just Posted

Last stop: The inside story of Queen City Shuttle and Charters’ closure

Former employees open up about the Nelson company’s final days

How the Queen City Shuttle and Charters’ closure affected you

Here’s what readers had to say about the company’s shutdown

LETTER: Clearing up men’s conference confusion

From conference organizer Jeff Zak

IODE and Kootenay Emergency Response celebrate partnership

IODE has pledged $30,000 to KERPA over the next three years

Andrew Bellerby out as RDCK’s regional fire chief

Bellerby held the job since January 2016

Feds lowered poverty line, reducing the number of seniors in need: documents

Liberals introduced a poverty line that was below the prior low-income cutoff

BCHL: Alberni Valley Bulldogs have been sold

Victoria company has purchased BCHL team, but will keep it in Port Alberni

Justin Trudeau’s carbon footprint revealed in ranking of world leaders

Travel company ranks 15 world leaders’ foreign flight CO2 emissions

“Does Kirby care?” B.C. First Nation’s group using geo-targeted ads in Houston, Texas for justice

The Heiltsuk Tribal Council has called out Kirby Corporation for the Nathan E. Stewart oil spill

Trudeau announces $79M investment for 118 more public transit buses across B.C.

Contributions from municipal to federal level to fund more buses in a bid to cut commutes

B.C. woman wins record $2.1 million on casino slot machine

‘That night was so surreal … I wasn’t able to sleep or eat for the first two days,’ she said

After B.C. dad’s death, Technical Safety BC wants changes to trampoline park rules

Jay Greenwood, 46, did ‘a series of acrobatic manoeuvres prior to a fall that caused serious injury and cardiac arrest’

$900M settlement reached in class action on sexual misconduct in Canadian military

After facing criticism, the government moved to begin settlement proceedings in early 2018

Tax take stays ahead of increased B.C. government spending

Tax revenue $2.1 billion higher than budget in 2018-19

Most Read